Skip to content

Identifying and Documenting Excessive Fees

Identifying and Documenting Excessive Fees

Farallon helps insurance company identify excessive cleanup fees

When an insurance company suspected it was being overcharged for cleanup of a dry cleaning site, it turned to Farallon to investigate.

Get In Touch

An insurance company responsible for a cleanup effort lasting more than 6 years at an annual cost of hundreds of thousands of dollars needed third-party review of the cleanup contractor’s work. An extensive record of successful cleanup actions at dry cleaning sites made Farallon the perfect choice for expert review. After examining thousands of pages of documentation, Farallon was able to demonstrate that the cleanup contractor’s charges were beyond what normally would be considered reasonable and necessary. Farallon presented its findings to the client’s legal counsel, and provided technical support that resulted in a favorable settlement.

Property owners often require a tenant who operates a dry cleaning facility to maintain insurance coverage against environmental damages resulting from spills of hazardous substances. These policies insure the property owner and the operator of the dry cleaning facility against remedial investigation and cleanup costs. In this case with mounting cleanup costs and no end in sight, the insurance company suspected fraud, and turned to Farallon to conduct third-party review of project-related technical documents and costs.

“We had to go through vast amounts of information and figure how to convey our findings succinctly and in a manner that would be understandable to lay people,” said Clifford T. Schmitt, Principle-in-Charge. To accomplish this, Farallon used a color-coding system to reveal patterns and showcase errors. In one instance, it was clear that pages in a report were simply copied from a previous year’s report with minimal changes.

Farallon presented its findings to legal counsel and the parties involved: the client, the insured owner, and the cleanup contractor. “We were able to communicate clearly and understandably that the consultant’s fees were excessive in relation to the services performed,” said Schmitt. “This led to a settlement in which the insurance company was granted a release from further obligation, something that is rarely ever done.”

Expertise

Services Utilized

Cost Audits

As part of our cost auditing services, we assess the reasonableness and necessity of investigation and cleanup expenses. We also support categorization of costs as indemnity versus defense, estimate future costs to support forecasting...

Read more

Insurance Claim Evaluation

We provide technical support to insurance carriers administering claims for contaminated properties and evaluating environmental risk affecting issuance of new insurance policies.

Read more
People

Meet Our Experts

headshot of Clifford Schmitt Clifford T. Schmitt Principal Hydrogeologist, Cofounder

Cliff is a licensed geologist and hydrogeologist in Washington and California. He has 35 years of experience in investigation and cleanup project management

Contact Us

Get In Touch







    This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.


    This website requires cookies to provide all of its features. For more information on what data is contained in the cookies, please see our Privacy Policy page. By continuing to use this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy.